Name | When Appointed |
| Christopher Hussey | No record. |
| William Godfrey | No record. |
| Robert Page | No record. |
| Francis Page | No record. |
| Thomas Dearborn | 1699, Nov. 1 |
| Thomas Philbrick | 1699, Nov. 1 |
| Gershom Elkins | 1706, Nov. 26 |
| Samuel Shaw | 1706, Nov. 26 |
| Samuel Dow | 1711, Jan. 30 |
| Philemon Dalton | 1714, July 19 |
| John Tuck | 1714, July 19 |
| John Dearborn, son of Henry | 1721, Apr. 20 |
| John Dearborn, son of John | No record |
| Josiah Moulton, Jr. | No record |
| Amos Towle, Jr. | No record |
| Joseph Philbrick | 1739, Jan. 29 |
| Jonathan Tuck | 1742, Feb. 17 |
| Samuel Dow | 1746, May 7 |
| Joshua Lane | 1755, Apr. 18 |
| Amos Towle | No record |
| Samuel Lane | 1776, Dec. 31 |
| Samuel Garland | No record |
| John A. Towle | No record |
| Jonathan Garland | 1798, July 5 |
| John Batchelder | 1821, July 22 |
| Jesse Knowles | 1838, June 9 |
| Morris Hobbs | 1840, Aug. 14 |
| David B. Elkins | 1850, Jan. 27 |
| Morris Hobbs | 1850, Jan. 27 |
| Samuel Drake | 1856, Sept. 28 |
| Joseph Dow | 1857, Feb. 26 |
| James Perkins | 1861, Oct. 4 |
| John Willcutt | 1872, May 26 |
| James Perkins | 1875, Sept. 26 |
| Josiah J. Dearborn | 1884, Nov. 2 |
| Jeremiah Locke | 1884, Nov. 9 |